Suldokar's Wake First Impressions

I received my copy of the Suldokar’s Wake pre-release (along with a fancy Whitehack Pocket).

image of Suldokar's Wake next to Whitehack Pocket Edition and some dice

As I’ve noted before, Whitehack is a go-to game for me, and I was extremely excited to hear about this new game from the same author.

As with Whitehack four years ago, I can tell it’s going to take some time to fully grok Suldokar, but also as with WH – even at first glance I am enthralled!

A few first impressions:

  • though I understand the format will change for final release, this little book is a pleasure to carry around & read
  • the sketched-out setting is quite compelling from the first seven words: “For ages, the bug-ridden machine bard”
  • I am surprisingly enthused by the notion of adventure modules meant to be fully utilized and even intentionally read aloud from without irony – this is a bold choice for an “old school” game & I am excited to see where it goes

Other than that, from my first speedy read-through my impression of the rules: this game system is tight. Reading through doesn’t give that impression at first, but when I reached the end of chapter 3 (probably the Harm section) I began to see how the different pieces hooked together so neatly. As with Whitehack, this is a game book I’ll be reading over & over again – and probably stealing from with abandon!

More here I’m sure as I digest this game! And I’m very much looking forward to following the progress as it develops toward final release.

If you want to learn more about this game-in-development:

Hiding Exploring Talking

Last night’s session at the open table involved a single quick & overwhelming combat, followed by retreat, leading into an entire session’s worth of sneaking about, making maps, and eventually: talking with underworld denizens!

Since the last post there have been several further expeditions, including one back to the delve beneath the watchtower, and then several closer to home, exploring the abandoned Rode Manor and the secret dungeon under its mausoleum. For details on all these, the campaign log is available as a summary, and the full chat records are archived on the discord server.

Meanwhile, I’d like to bring special attention to last night’s session 7. We’ve shifted to Thursday evenings for a few weeks, and some of the regulars are unable to make the game, so we were down to three players. We instituted a house rule allowing players to bring lower-level PCs from their stable as retainers, so the party consisted of 3 “primary” PCs, 2 additional PCs as retainers (semi-autonomous and subject to morale), and the kid torchbearer Tork.

Even with the retainers I think the party felt a little small, and thus cautious. The under-mausoleum had been explored a bit in the previous session, but had revealed itself to be well-populated and probably quite dangerous. The party proceeded with caution.

However, they almost immediately (second door opening) ran into a large group of the walking dead. Trying to make a fighting retreat (back to the first door), they were nearly overwhelmed when one of the retainers, Martel, went down with 0hp. Thanks to Alex’s Death & Dismemberment table from Halberds & Helmets fresh-faced Martel did not perish, but instead lost his (roll of 6, roll of 1) nose, which the dead tore from his face in the scuffle!

This terrible loss sufficiently spooked the party that they decided to break & run. They made it back to the first door, slammed it, held it, and spiked it.

And then ensued most of an entire session spent sneaking about and avoiding conflict. The party would creep up to a door, listen carefully, and either spike the door, or creep off again. The entire time they were taking careful notes, so as we neared the end of the session, they’d penciled in the locations of several factions, and identified several loops in the dungeon structure that would give them a tactical advantage if it came to conflict.

Two walking wounded out of five was enough to encourage this quiet, exploratory approach (rather than a more violent kick-the-door style).

As session end approached, the party opened a door to find a group of half-sized people on the other side. These were neutrals, and the reaction check was good, so a conversation ensued which set the tone for the rest of the session: talking to neutral factions about the layout of the dungeon, getting info, and making approaches to alliance.

So while the party found no treasure, they managed to explore perhaps a third of the level, and get a good idea for where the dangerous factions might be. They also identified some interesting doors behind which treasure might surely lie… And finally, because of their willingness to talk, they turned up a possible job with the wizard occupying the northwest quadrant of the level.

All-in-all I felt it was a session very well played on the party’s side, so I awarded an amount of XP just for the sake of exploration.

Many leads have been turned up, and we shall see which ones are to be followed next week.

If the above sounds interesting to you, there’s always room at the table if you care to join!


Session Report 2 and 3

Two more expeditions have been made beneath the Raven Hill watchtower.

First, a party went back to the watchtower to seek out & destroy the creature Rikard (who they met in session 1).

The party returned to the watchtower, intent on killing Rikard. They busted the door & were attacked by giant ferrets, leading to Ymar having his arm broken (though quick magical work from Terg saved his life. Once the ferrets were vanquished, they continue through the trapdoor down into the depths. The strange red underwold torches were all extuingished. In Rikard’s old room they met Ornir, a flunky of some kind who passed them a message from Rikard, but was convinced to join them in killing the bad guy (he seemed to have a grievance against his boss).

So, guided by Ornir, the party went down to the 2nd level. There they were ambushed in the process of setting their own ambush, but managed to retreat in order. Then they taunted Rikard out of the safety of his ranks, and shot him down in cold blood.

This did not please his many underlings, who charged, but a well-timed spell from Gale opened a pit to hold off the charge, and the party grabbed Rikard’s body & sword, and fled the scene!

Next, a party led by Lem the Fighter went into the halls beneath the watchtower, and chose to explore beyond the skull door. There they found several sarcophagi, sealed chambers, catacombs, and a room with a large mosaic depicting the life of a bug-eyed dead man. One corpse came to life and was exterminated. They found an emerald in the lid of a tomb, and a magical dagger, but beat an ordered retreat when assailed by skeleton guardians of the crypts.

Session reports are available for session 2 and session 3.

There is also a Campaign Log with summaries and links to the individual reports.

And the chat logs are on the Discord server as usual.

The next expedition heads out next Sunday!

A Silver-Based Market with City & Rural Prices for Early Rules Games

I’ve prepared an equipment list for my open table, which:

  • is meant for earliest rules traditions (all weapons deal 1d6 damage in normal combat)
  • is priced to a silver piece (SP) standard
  • has city & rural prices
  • is Open Game Content

Given the above perks, I thought it might be useful for others.

Here are the available formats:

The list is also included at the end of this post.

If you have a comment, an issue, would like to generate your own additional formats, or would like to collaborate, source files can be found on gitlab:

Collaboration is especially encouraged: add weights, add more equipment, fix errors, etc! Pull/merge requests will be reviewed & probably accepted!

It took me a few hours to get this content together in a usable format. If you end up using it, consider dropping a tip in my ko-fi jar.

Open Market

Open Market by Andrew Codispoti is ©2019. It can be found at with source files at

The following equipment price tables & accompanying explanatory text are Open Game Content under the terms of the Open Game License 1.0a, which should be distributed with this content, either at the end of a generated document (such as PDF, HTML, or ODT), or as an accompanying, and which is always available at

The Market

General Notes

You may sell used or looted items back to the market for half price.

Italicized items are considered Non-Encumbering items for encumbrance purposes, although the Referee can rule that quantities of the items do count towards encumbrance. Items listed in underline are considered to be Oversized.


Light25 sp50sp7
Barding, light250sp7
Barding, medium500sp5
Barding, heavy1,000sp3



Lance30spcharge from horseback
Spear5sp3spstrike from second rank
Weapon, Minor5sp5spdaggers, knives, etc
Weapon, small10sp10spshort sword, hand axe, etc
Weapon, medium20sp50sparming sword, battle axe, mace, flail, etc
Weapon, great50spgreat axe, longsword, maul, etc
Whip10sp25spcan entangle


Bow, long45sp
Bow, short25sp25sp
Crossbow, heavy30sp
Crossbow, light25sp
Other thrown weaponsas meleeas melee

General Equipment


Carrier Pigeon100sp100sp
Horse, riding100sp100sp
Horse, war500sp




Boat, raft5sp5sp
Boat, canoe30sp25sp


Bottle of Wine/Liquor, Poor5cp2cp
Bottle of Wine/Liquor, Decent> 1sp> 1sp
Bottle of Wine/Liquor, Rich> 10sp
Drink, cheap1cp1cp
Drink, decent3cp2cp
Drink, good6cp4cp
Drink, rich> 15sp> 10sp
Meal, fancy1sp5cp
Meal, horrid2cp1cp
Meal, rich> 15sp> 10sp
Meal, standard5cp3cp
Rations, iron per day2sp1sp
Rations, standard per day1sp5cp
Feed, animal per day1sp5cp


Inn, poor1sp5cp
Inn, average5sp2sp
Inn, secure10sp5sp
Inn, fancy> 25sp> 2sp
Inn, extravagant> 100sp> 25sp
Rent, 1 month (per 10’ sq.)30sp15sp

Costs are per day, unless noted. The cost to buy instead of rent is one hundred times the listed monthly rental price.


Air bladder1sp1sp
Block & tackle2sp3sp
Book, blank5sp10sp
Book, reading10sp20sp
Book, spell (blank)100sp
Chain, per foot1sp2sp
Clothing, extravagant> 20sp
Clothing, normal5sp2sp
Clothing, poor1sp5cp
Clothing, winter travel10sp5sp
Cooking pots1sp5cp
Fishing gear1sp1sp
Flask of lamp oil2sp2sp
Gem> 5sp> 5sp
Grappling hook5sp10sp
Holy symbol, silver25sp50sp
Holy symbol, steel10sp10sp
Holy symbol, wood1sp1cp
Holy water25sp25sp
Instrument, musical> 1sp> 5sp
Jewelry> 10sp> 10sp
Ladder, 10’10sp7sp
Map, local1sp5sp
Mirror, glass10sp15sp
Mirror, silver30sp
Mirror, steel1sp5sp
Pick, miner’s6sp12sp
Pole, 10’1sp5cp
Riding gear25sp10sp
Rope, 50’3sp3sp
Scroll case1sp3sp
Specialist’s tools50sp
Spike, iron3cp5cp
Spike, wooden1cp1cp
Tent, grand25sp
Tent, pavilion50sp
Tent, personal5sp10sp
tent, regular10sp20sp
Vial or bottle, empty5cp7cp


The following text is the property of Wizards of the Coast, Inc. and is Copyright 2000 Wizards of the Coast, Inc (“Wizards”). All Rights Reserved.

  1. Definitions: (a)“Contributors” means the copyright and/or trademark owners who have contributed Open Game Content; (b)“Derivative Material” means copyrighted material including derivative works and translations (including into other computer languages), potation, modification, correction, addition, extension, upgrade, improvement, compilation, abridgment or other form in which an existing work may be recast, transformed or adapted; © “Distribute” means to reproduce, license, rent, lease, sell, broadcast, publicly display, transmit or otherwise distribute; (d)“Open Game Content” means the game mechanic and includes the methods, procedures, processes and routines to the extent such content does not embody the Product Identity and is an enhancement over the prior art and any additional content clearly identified as Open Game Content by the Contributor, and means any work covered by this License, including translations and derivative works under copyright law, but specifically excludes Product Identity. (e) “Product Identity” means product and product line names, logos and identifying marks including trade dress; artifacts; creatures characters; stories, storylines, plots, thematic elements, dialogue, incidents, language, artwork, symbols, designs, depictions, likenesses, formats, poses, concepts, themes and graphic, photographic and other visual or audio representations; names and descriptions of characters, spells, enchantments, personalities, teams, personas, likenesses and special abilities; places, locations, environments, creatures, equipment, magical or supernatural abilities or effects, logos, symbols, or graphic designs; and any other trademark or registered trademark clearly identified as Product identity by the owner of the Product Identity, and which specifically excludes the Open Game Content; (f) “Trademark” means the logos, names, mark, sign, motto, designs that are used by a Contributor to identify itself or its products or the associated products contributed to the Open Game License by the Contributor (g) “Use”, “Used” or “Using” means to use, Distribute, copy, edit, format, modify, translate and otherwise create Derivative Material of Open Game Content. (h) “You” or “Your” means the licensee in terms of this agreement.
  2. The License: This License applies to any Open Game Content that contains a notice indicating that the Open Game Content may only be Used under and in terms of this License. You must affix such a notice to any Open Game Content that you Use. No terms may be added to or subtracted from this License except as described by the License itself. No other terms or conditions may be applied to any Open Game Content distributed using this License.
  3. Offer and Acceptance: By Using the Open Game Content You indicate Your acceptance of the terms of this License.
  4. Grant and Consideration: In consideration for agreeing to use this License, the Contributors grant You a perpetual, worldwide, royalty-free, non-exclusive license with the exact terms of this License to Use, the Open Game Content.
  5. Representation of Authority to Contribute: If You are contributing original material as Open Game Content, You represent that Your Contributions are Your original creation and/or You have sufficient rights to grant the rights conveyed by this License.
  6. Notice of License Copyright: You must update the COPYRIGHT NOTICE portion of this License to include the exact text of the COPYRIGHT NOTICE of any Open Game Content You are copying, modifying or distributing, and You must add the title, the copyright date, and the copyright holder’s name to the COPYRIGHT NOTICE of any original Open Game Content you Distribute.
  7. Use of Product Identity: You agree not to Use any Product Identity, including as an indication as to compatibility, except as expressly licensed in another, independent Agreement with the owner of each element of that Product Identity. You agree not to indicate compatibility or co-adaptability with any Trademark or Registered Trademark in conjunction with a work containing Open Game Content except as expressly licensed in another, independent Agreement with the owner of such Trademark or Registered Trademark. The use of any Product Identity in Open Game Content does not constitute a challenge to the ownership of that Product Identity. The owner of any Product Identity used in Open Game Content shall retain all rights, title and interest in and to that Product Identity.
  8. Identification: If you distribute Open Game Content You must clearly indicate which portions of the work that you are distributing are Open Game Content.
  9. Updating the License: Wizards or its designated Agents may publish updated versions of this License. You may use any authorized version of this License to copy, modify and distribute any Open Game Content originally distributed under any version of this License.
  10. Copy of this License: You MUST include a copy of this License with every copy of the Open Game Content You Distribute.
  11. Use of Contributor Credits: You may not market or advertise the Open Game Content using the name of any Contributor unless You have written permission from the Contributor to do so.
  12. Inability to Comply: If it is impossible for You to comply with any of the terms of this License with respect to some or all of the Open Game Content due to statute, judicial order, or governmental regulation then You may not Use any Open Game Material so affected.
  13. Termination: This License will terminate automatically if You fail to comply with all terms herein and fail to cure such breach within 30 days of becoming aware of the breach. All sublicenses shall survive the termination of this License.
  14. Reformation: If any provision of this License is held to be unenforceable, such provision shall be reformed only to the extent necessary to make it enforceable.
  • Open Game License v 1.0 Copyright 2000, Wizards of the Coast, Inc.
  • System Reference Document © 2000, Wizards of the Coast, Inc.; Authors Jonathon Tweet, Monte Cook, Skip Williams, based on original material by E. Gary Gygax and Dave Arneson.
  • System Reference Document Copyright 2000-2003, Wizards of the Coast, Inc.; Authors Jonathan Tweet, Monte Cook, Skip Williams, Rich Baker, Andy Collins, David Noonan, Rich Redman, Bruce R. Cordell, John D. Rateliff, Thomas Reid, James Wyatt, based on original material by E. Gary Gygax and Dave Arneson.
  • Modern System Reference Document Copyright 2002-2004, Wizards of the Coast, Inc.; Authors Bill Slavicsek, Jeff Grubb, Rich Redman, Charles Ryan, Eric Cagle, David Noonan, Stan!, Christopher Perkins, Rodney Thompson, and JD Wiker, based on material by Jonathan Tweet, Monte Cook, Skip Williams, Richard Baker, Peter Adkison, Bruce R. Cordell, John Tynes, Andy Collins, and JD Wiker.
  • Castles & Crusades: Players Handbook, Copyright 2004, Troll Lord Games; Authors Davis Chenault and Mac Golden.
  • Castles & Crusades: Monsters Product Support, ©2005, Troll Lord Games.
  • Basic Fantasy Role-Playing Game Copyright ©2006–2008 Chris Gonnerman.
  • New Spells: A Basic Fantasy Supplement Copyright © 2007 Chris Gonnerman, Ola Berg, Angelo Bertolli, Jeff Querner, Everett Bradshaw, Emiliano Marchetti,Ethan Moore, Jim Bobb, and Scott Abraham.
  • OSRIC™ © 2006, Stuart Marshall, adapting material prepared by Matthew J. Finch, based upon the System Reference Document, and inspired by the works of E. Gary Gygax, Dave Arneson, and many others.
  • Labyrinth Lord™ Copyright 2007-2009, Daniel Proctor, Author Daniel Proctor.
  • Swords & Wizardry Core Rules, © 2008, Matthew J. Finch
  • Eldritch Weirdness, Book One, © 2008, Matthew J. Finch
  • Darwin’s World © 2002, RPGObjects; Authors Dominic Covey and Chris Davis.
  • Mutant FutureTM © 2008, Daniel Proctor and Ryan Denison. Authors Daniel Proctor and Ryan Denison.
  • Advanced Edition Companion, © 2009–2010, Daniel Proctor. Author Daniel Proctor.
  • Lamentations of the Flame Princess: Weird Fantasy Role-Playing Deluxe Edition, © 2010, LotFP. Author James Edward Raggi IV
  • First Level Magic-User Spells Grindhouse Edition Spell Contest: Bookspeak, © 2011 Daniel Smith
  • First Level Magic-User Spells Grindhouse Edition Spell Contest: Howl of the Moon, © 2011 Joel Rojas)
  • Lamentations of the Flame Princess: Weird Fantasy Role-Playing Grindhouse Edition, © 2011, LotFP, Author James Edward Raggi IV
  • Lamentations of the Flame Princess: Weird Fantasy Role-Playing Player Core Book: Rules & Magic © 2013 LotFP, author James Edward Raggi IV
  • Open Market © 2019, Andrew Codispoti.

Session Report 1

The first session of the Werdna World Open Table was yesterday.

Five treasure-seekers ventured up the ridge of Raven Hill looking for a cave. They found a broken watchtower with a new door on the exterior, and a trapdoor within.

Beneath the trapdoor: a spiral staircase that led them deep into the earth over ancient stone steps.

At the bottom they surprised & overcame two strange & troubling small-man-sized creatures, but one escaped to draw reinforcements. The reinforcements were burned & held off with a smashed lamp fueled by extra oil, and the lone survivor interrogated to little success.

Some of the creatures speak the common tongue, but others speak only their only strange gibber.

Pressing forward, the party came upon a much taller, more menacing specimen (apparently called Rikard) which conversed in the common tongue, then threatened them. The party slew another smaller creature on the way out, but Rikard was unharmed.

The party beat a retreat at this point & returned to Haven Town with some combat under their belts & a strange tale to tell.

The five survivors have gained experience, and indeed, have attained 1st level and chosen classes. We now have 3 Fighters and 2 Sorcerers.

A session record is available. And the chat log is on the Discord server if you care to read the actual play.

Plans will soon be under way for session two, and there are always seats at the digital table!

Bare Bones Setting

I’m starting an open table game February 10th (this Sunday), and I’m writing a series of articles about how I’m going about preparing for the game. After the game starts I’ll continue the series with articles about how play progresses.

Last time I wrote about the character creation process I’m using for this campaign.

Today’s topic is the bare-bones “setting” I’ll have in place for the first session, and a bit about how I intend it to grow during play.

For the past few years I begin most of my campaigns in the same way, essentially creating a new version of the same campaign setting for each game. Continuity is generally preserved during a particular campaign (i.e. with the same gaming group), but I want each new group to have their chance to spin the world off in an interesting direction, and I also want to give myself a fresh view on the setting, so I do a “reset” for each separate game group.

This is what I start with:

  • a safe town called Haven
  • a hill outside of town covered in ruins, called Raven Hill
  • a town in a swamp at the edge of the map, called Brack
  • two or three other significant features on the map, either named or unnamed, i.e. interesting places (this time around: a deep, dark forest, a weird mountain with what might be a volcano near it, and an unnamed settlement or way station on the southern edge of the map)

At this point, I know Haven Town fairly well. It serves as the PCs’ home base, and is considered safe (i.e. any expedition can begin or end there without risk). Multiple groups have spent varying amounts of time in Haven Town over the years. Interesting NPCs have been developed, and a bit of the landscape of the town, but for each new game I give myself permission to change these details in response to the particular happenings in th new game.

Raven Hill is a large enough feature to house multiple dungeons, and indeed it does! There are several entrances from the ruins on its peak, and from caves (hidden and obvious) along its shoulders. I usually place the same few dungeons upon Raven Hill, but again, I give myself permission to change these up depening on how things develop.

For this open table game, the first session is going to begin at the entrance to one of the dungeons on Raven Hill.

The Town of Brack, and the other mysterious features on the map, are meant to be hooks that draw the players out into exploration of the wilderness. Brack is in dangerous territory (a swamp), and it is placed far enough from Haven to entail a non-trivial expedition for beginning characters. There are also rumours that Brack itself is dangerous and crime-ridden. The precise nature of Brack, of course, will be determined during play.

For the other features, I try to come up with new ones each time.

The above is the limit of what I’m going to write about the setting before the first session, and probably for a while after that (though this will depend on what expedition the players choose for sessions after the ifirst).

My primary aim in using this structure are probably pretty clear: I want to give the players lots of interesting places on the map to explore once they tire of exploring the first dungeon (which is itself placed a little way outside town).

In starting afresh with each game group, I’m also giving myself some fun: I like to play to find out what happens just as much as the players (hopefully) do. Though I can guess, with pretty good accuracy, what is behind most of the features on the map at this point, I don’t set it for sure (write it down) until I’ve had a little input from the players – just in terms of seeing what kinds of places they want to explore, what kinds of problems they want to solve.

If the players end up returning again and again to the first dungeon until they’ve cleared it entirely (though that would take some doing), I probably won’t add too much detail to the wilderness features for some time, though I may add a bit of background to Haven as they spend time there recovering & preparing.

Needless to say, every feature on the map is as full as Raven Hill: there are dungeons even within the town of Haven, if one cares to look. There’s plent of room for this world to expand down as well as out.

In the next article I’ll take a look at the first dungeon on Raven Hill.

Character Creation

I’m starting an open table next Sunday, and this is the first of a series of companion articles here on my blog. I plan to cover mainly how I’m going about planning for this campaign setting, especially as it regards my practice of “just-in-time planning”.

Today’s topic, however, is how I’m handling character generation for this campaign.

As I mentioned above, the campaign is an “open table” setup. As GM, I post the dates & times when I’m open to running a session. Players then sign up to play in that expedition. Expeditions begin & end in a “safe haven”, e.g. the starting town, so there’s no need to commit to joining each weekly expedition. Whoever is available ventures out that week.

The rules system is what I’m calling “OD&Dish”. It’s basically original edition D&D, just the three little brown books, & none of the supplements. I’m using Delving Deeper as my primary reference, but I’ll also refer to the three booklets themselves, and will introduce house rules as they occur to me.

These rules tend to create delicate characters, and to exacerbate this effect, I’m creating characters at 0-level (more on this in a moment).

The combination of open table (not knowing who might be playing very far ahead of time), and delicate characters, means that I want character generation to be very quick. I also want the game to be easy for new players or even first time players to jump into.

Therefore, I’ve chosen to make character creation completely random for beginning players.

How this works:

  1. a player signs up to join the game & requests a character
  2. I roll up the character:
    1. 3d6 down the line (Strength, Intelligence, Wisdom, Dexterity, Constitution, Charisma)
    2. 1d6 hit points (i.e. a single hit die)
    3. random equipment using this table from Necropraxis
    4. a bit of background colour from James West, i.e. the relationship tables (1d6, 1d20) and the “raised by” table (1d20)
  3. I then ask the player to name the resulting character.

As I mentioned above, characters for all players start out at level 0. They have a single hit die, but no class.

The process takes about a minute, and can be used to quickly generate a new character for new players or for a player whose character has fallen.

I like it because it generates interesting, often paradoxical characters. E.g. great Srength, very little hp. Or little hp, but heavy armor. Etc.

Asking the players to provide the name often solidifies the character in interesting ways, suddenly providing, for example, an idea of gender, background, personality, and even vocation, all of which might be completely different from what I might have assumed the character would be about given their ability scores.

James’ background tables are excellent: they are evocative but leave plenty of room for interpretation. I chose the relationship & raised-by tables because they create a concrete bond to somebody in the world (though who knows when we shall meet them), and they tell us just a bit about where this character is coming from.

Any other detail I leave to the players, though at this point most seem quite content to see what happens to these oddballs in their first expedition, without adding further detail.

Once a character survives their first expedition (i.e. makes it back to a haven) the players gets to choose a class (Fighter, Thief, Magic-User) for the character, and the character comes just a little bit more alive.

I am considering a rule for later play:

Once a player has raised a character to level 3, they can (at their option) create new 1st level characters (i.e. characters that begin with class), and they need not be determined entirely at random.

We’ll see how we feel about the above rule when we get to that point in the campaign.

The next article is going to cover how I create extremely minimal setting for this campaign (a practice I’ve been following with pleasant results for a few years now).

Creative Burden in DnD

Brad wrote about locating the creative burden in RPGs: is it primarily on the ref, or the players, a mixture of both?

The following are my free-writ thoughts in response.

I’ve played a fair number of games (including a couple of Brad’s) where the creative burden is explicity shared out among the players & the ref to some extent. I’ve played games where there is no ref & the rules share the burden out among the players all on equal grounds. From my point of view, the creative burden is being spread around the table in most games that I play, including DnD. It’s not that a player has less creative responsibility than the GM, it’s just a different kind of responsibility.

I should say at the start that the “rulings-not-rules” maxim & associated discussion has never held much meaning for me. From my point of view, early DnD has plenty of rules, and I don’t find myself needing to exercise a lot of creativity in order to apply them in any given situation (i.e. make a ruling). Thus, I don’t feel the GM has to fill up gaps in the rules by creatively applying rules.

I’m more interested in the creative burden of generating setting & narrative (or I might say context & movement).

In DnD the ref seems to hold a lot of the creative burden because they are responsible for the setting the PCs are to explore, and for making that setting feel alive during play (context & movement).

But the players have a huge creative burden as well: they participate with the GM in making the setting real (by active listening or engaging with visual aids like drawings or miniatures), and then they must take action within that context by imagining either what they or a very specific fictional person would do in that context.

Brad asked:

So where is the creative burden in your favourite game?

And I think my response is that the creative burden in DnD, as I have played it for the past several years, is fairly evening spread out between the ref & the players, but that the specific nature of the burden is asymmetric: the GM creates a fictional world & its reactions to player action, while the players actively (& creatively) receive that world, and create their PCs actions in response to it and in context of it.

My background is in theatre, and I spend much of my life finding space for my own creativity around a script. No one doubts that an actor shows great creativity & shoulders a heavy burden when interpreting the words of a playwright. The player’s burden in an RPG is similar. However, while I almost always feel myself to be creating in collaboration with a playwright, how much more so is a player creating in collaboration with the GM? My playwright may be completely inaccessible to me as a person – in fact most of my work is done in collaborate with Mr. Wm. Shakespeare, who’s been dead four hundred years and is very inaccesible as a person at the best of times due to his damnable aura of mystery – whereas the player sits at table with the GM, sharing the air they breathe & the vibrations of voice in the room.

To come around to a conclusion, I’ve always felt the creative dynamic of RPGs (including DnD) to be very much a two-way street, or more accurately an agora of the table, where creativity is shared.

Actually, the analogy is hitting me in the face at this point:

DnD is like a theatre production: the rules & setting are the script, a sturdy framework; the DM is the director, responsible for speaking for the rules & setting and keeping an eye on the overall effect; the players are the actors & other individual craftspeople, each with their part to play. (Arguably) there is no production without the script, the director, or the actors – they share the burden in order to create the thing.

But it’s always a collaboration.

Open Table Recruiting Players

Starting on February 10th I’m going to GM a weekly game via Discord text chat. You’re welcome to join as a player, or as an observer if you wish!

The rules will be something in the neighborhood of OD&D (no supplements), with Delving Deeper v4 as the primary reference text.

Characters will be generated at random & start at 0-level.

Play will focus on exploration of dungeons & wilderness. I’ll start this campaign (as I usually do) with a very bare-bones setting, in this case just a dungeon & a safe town. The setting will evolve just as the rules do: in response to play & the particularly the players’ actions.

I plan to post on this blog about the setting creation process & the house rules. I may also post session reports here.

The format is inspired by West Marches & Rythlondar Chronicle: each session begins and ends in a safe area, and anyone with a character can join in for a single session (expedition), with no commitment to being there the following session.

Emphasis is on fun, casual, low-commitment, and playing to find out what happens, for myself as well as the players.

Sessions are currently scheduled for Sundays starting Feb 10, 1-4pm EST.

If you want to join, it’s as easy as joining my Discord server & requesting a character. Here is the link to join:

If you’d like to learn more, there’s the beginnings of a campaign wiki here:

Hope to see you in Werdna World!